jar of peanut butter

This is a jar of Gimlet peanut butter, a brand primarily noted for arguments about how to pronounce it. According to the manufacturer, it rhymes with "Himlet."

Reduces your Moxie by 3 for the rest of the day

Sell Value: 20

Acquired From

• Halloway's Hideaway

Effect

• Buttermouthed

Notes

• Can be fed to your horse while in Dirtwater to gain 100 XP (500 XP if you have Friend of Horses perk).
• If fed to a Crazy Horse specifically, it will start speaking random words, including the intro to the song "All Star" by Smash Mouth.
• If fed to a Pale Horse, it will talk to you about the afterlife.
• The ability of the peanut butter to make horses talk is most likely a reference to Mister Ed, the television show about a talking horse. The effect of the titular horse "talking" was achieved by feeding it peanut butter between takes so that it would move its mouth along with the voiceover.